She would not come out! We went ahead and lined up all of Jaxon's bath toys so that she could pick the one she had been after:
She literally went toy by toy, sniffing each one until BINGO! she found the one.... the crab.
She was beyond happy to finally have her paws on the crab. I would like to say that there will be peace in our house, but I now better. She will find a new bath toy to obsess over and I am sure she will take over that one too.